Showing posts with label Reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Wikipedia Annual Donation Campaign


By the end of the year, Wikipedia will kick-off its fundrasing campaign though banner notice on each page to encourage users' donation (you can always choose to hide the notice) . As someone who always plans to edit more entries but fails to do so, writing a check is the best way to technically accomplish the plan (though a very small amount). Later one day, I read a tweet saying why Wikipedia does not keep advertising on each page. In that way, users can choose to view the ad or not, and Wiki dont need to do this donation campaign again and again every time.

It sounds O.K. at first glance because we've already get used to advertising-supported free content, and this turn on/off ad option keeps some voluntary meaning. However, in my mind, I just automatically rejected this idea and did not know why. This week, as I finished the book Predictable Irrational (Dan Ariely, 2008, HaperCollins), I found the answer to my spontaneous reaction.

In this enlightening book, the author conducts all kinds of focus group experiments to study behavioral economics. One chapter is about the cost of social norms and market norms. Sometimes, we put a lot efforts to do something but dont expect the cash pay back, for instance, cooking Thanks Giving dish for the family, the example in the book. This is the social norm. On the other hand, we expect that when we sit in the office for 8 hours (even just browsing Facebook page), we are adding money to our account. This is the market norm.

Researchers did an experiment in a day care center: initially, there was no fine for being late to pick up the children. The parents and the teachers understand the situation based on social norms that people do get late occasionally and they should not do that again to bother teachers. Then, the day care center imposed a fine of being late. Since a pay relationship is involved, the social encounter is being replaced by market norms that parents can choose to be late or not. And the late cases did not decrease as expected. Then, when the center dropped the fine , getting back to the social contract, parents still pick their kids late, even slightly more often. The author concludes from this experiment that social relationship will not be reestablished easily once it is trumped by the market norm.

And, this explains why Wikipedia cant not use advertising, even voluntarily, for funding. Advertising is totally a commercial concept following the market rule; let alone it will break Wikipedia’s neutral point of view, it will also ruin the collective efforts of Wikipedia as a social media foundation. Adding advertising essentially leads to market-value norms, even not for profits; once this market norm being introduced, the social norm, the volunteer spirit of Wikipeida will hardly be impaired.

As I finally figure out this puzzle, another question came to my mind. As social media becomes so overwhelming, how do we justify the “social meaning” when it is advertising supported? Is it another situation where social norms collide with market norm?

Monday, June 01, 2009

[Reading] Who Controls the Internet (2006)

Though written by two law experts, this book on Internet governance and related civil rights, copyright, and cyber criminal issues is written in a humor and light style. Especially the first few chapters, which introduce the early history of the Internet development, contrasting to the current situation, is like a adventure of Utopianists fight with state machine. The early experts' forecast of the Internet is full of idealism, but still inspiring, especially the story of the root authority, Jon Postel , which is referred as "the god of the Internet" in this book. Culturally, Internet definitely brings the grass-roots spirit to the world, even in the Central-controlled country; yet, realistically, it is a tool, a commercialized tool, initially for national defense purpose, it is impossible to avoid the impact of the commercialization and government interference.

The book is divided into three chapters, first part is about the early history of Internet, and the second part includes governments' involvement in the past years while the third part discusses the future and the global law. I think there should be an update of the book: when talking about the MGM v
Grokster case, the book only traced back to 2004, when the court still recognizes the technological innovation over contributory infringement of Grokster, so the book quoted "the death of copyright"(pp112). Actually, Grokster eventually lost the case in 2005, Gorkster is ruled as liable for infringement.

In the government control chapter, the authors devote a chapter for China, which makes me have to say something. The China chapter makes two point, the stringent control and the
CPC uses Internet as a tool to raise nationalism. I totally agree with the two facts.

Looking at how the mainstream media online treat the 512 Si
Chuan earthquake has demonstrated both points. Right after 2008, May12, the earthquake, the portal sites, such as SINA , SOHU, gave tons of information about the survivors, the casualty, the rescue team, which united the whole country by the efficient information flow. Now, a year later , we still dont know exactly how many students were buried during the earthquake and why those school buildings so easily crashed. Any negative news one 512 earthquake is sensitive information that is blocked by the GFW and by self-censorship of media. Independent blogger, Ai WeiWei, who conducted personal survey of the earthquake, has been 'invited' to talk to the police (Gong An), and his blog on SINA has been wiped out. Moreover, citizen journalist in that area (Wen Chuan, SiChuan Provence) were more or less targeted by the police (according to Ai weiwei's blog). With the coming 20-year anniversary of June 4th, no need to bother the GFW, the internal control of service providers and mainstream websites are sufficient, for instance, Baidu's university bulletin boards no longer allow users to post articles, you can just read but not comment; and some popular websites among youngsters also have deleted more information than past months by the end of May. And,Blogger has been completely blocked by GFW in May, 2009.

The authors have expressed deep concern of the censorship and the effective
control of Chinese government. I am just wondering how effective it really could be. Though being censored again and again, we now are able to hear Yang Jia's case or Deng Yujiao's case that we would otherwise never know and never pay attention to discuss. The really terrifying thing is not that they are blocking and censoring things, but they are threatening your safety and family safety in a lot cases since no legislation to protect citizen in these situations till now. The well-know government control of China's Internet actually mirrors the fragile legislation and litigation system in China.

Friday, January 02, 2009

[读书]《野火集》


2005年文汇出版社发行了《野火集:二十周年纪念版》,收录了龙应台在1985年返台的所见、所闻、所思、所想和其他人对野火系列的评论。2008年末,在野火系列文发表24年后,我才读了这本书。二十多年前让她心痛地台湾社会的方方面面,历历在目,就在上海,就在我身边。

“ 为了多赚几毛钱,有人把染了菌的针筒再度卖出,把病毒注入健康人的身体里去。为了物质享受,有人制造假的奶粉,明明知道可能害了几百个婴儿的性命。为了逃避责任,有人在肇事之后,回过头来把倒地呻吟的人瞄准了再碾一次。我们的子女坐在教室里,让毒气给轰倒。我们的朋友喝了伪劣的酒而失明。我们的兄弟,被车撞断了腿,每天拄着拐杖,一跛一跛上学。而我们自己,心平气和地吃喝各色各样地化学毒素,呼吸污浊的空气,在横行霸道的车辆间仓皇怯懦地苟活。

要遭到什么程度你才会大吃一惊。

《生了梅毒的母亲》原载于1985年1月4日’中国时报‘,收录于《野火集“二十周年纪念版》PP14-18”
龙应台把苏格拉底或是卢梭的故事都讲的很简单,也只选卖菜卖肉的老头老太或者是的哥的故事,意在让整个社会都能够接受,认真地思考。例如”难局“这一篇,讨论的是关于是做守法的受难者还是违法的反抗者,就让我想到了08年的杨佳案。他这个事件,事关制度问题,当他不相信制度可以保护他的时候,他还有什么选择来保住自己?在一个文明的法制社会,这本应该引起更多的重视和讨论,如今却只闻草根讨论。

不过,让我感触最深的是”美国不是我们的家“和”欧威尔的台湾?“这两篇。

前一篇说,17岁的读者寄信给龙应台,理直气壮地说”反正没有用!我要到美国去”。我跟一些出国的朋友讨论起来或者是在mitbbs上看起来,也或多或少感受到这份无力感。也曾跟来千里迢迢跑来上海参加公务员考试地外省同学说,我不是对你没信心,只是。。。唉。这份无力感是谁造成的?这种无力感会让多少人宁愿留在美国也不回国?我其实没什么信心。
后一篇事关教育和大众传媒,读来更加感慨。
“欧威尔的台湾?”这一篇是写在《新闻周刊》(Newsweek)在1985年8月5日刊登了一篇报道台湾政府严厉地言论控制的文章之后,龙应台反思台湾到底有没有言论自由,到底要不要言论自由。她说,没有言论自由地后果就是年轻一代变的非常地疑事(cynical,犬儒主义),矫枉过正的结果就是对于政府/媒体的不信任,而这只是一个方面,教育也受影响。一方面学校教育我们要实事求是,另一方面老师说作文不能太偏激,校报说这个题目不适合,家长说有些东西你还是不要问不要说。拿媒体的话说,“80后,90后”都冒起来了;拿我妈的酒后真言来说,希望就在你们下一代,可是一代又一代都是在这样的教育和媒体环境之中,何时才能有独立思考的能力,Chang在哪里?
说实话, 我就是一个不会生气,从小被“明哲保身,能忍责忍”的处世哲学教育长大的人,事隔这么多年读这些文章,犹感惭愧。大俗人一个,不管这本书里收录的评论多么精辟,我就只有四个字,说得真好。这本书也有点缺点,书里面有一些评论是些客套话,另有多篇文章结尾处属“本篇略有删节”,不知道这个“略”字是什么程度,什么原因。

Thursday, December 18, 2008

[读书]白夜行


感谢cherry同学提供货源和线索,一回家就看了东野圭吾的《嫌疑人X的献身》( 2005)以及《白夜行》(1999)。其中《白夜行》是2008年9月由南海出版公司出版的,由台湾独步出版社的版本翻过来的,虽然已经被电视剧虐过一遍了,合上书,还是悲从中来,难以自拔。

读书的时候必然受到了电视剧的干扰,好处是有画面感,缺点是难以扎抓东野圭吾真正想要表达感情。电视剧是着重了亮和雪穗的纯爱剧,柔化了很多阴暗面,加上了亮与母亲的感情,亮与典子的感情,甚至最后借亮的孩子之手给全剧一点温暖。小说则是步步为营的犯罪推理小说,亮和雪穗之间的关系是引导,1973年到1992年之间日本社会的变化是大的背景。东野圭吾本身就是大阪人,大学时代学的就是工科(大阪府立大学工学部電気工学科,wiki),所以描绘起70-80年代的大阪以及亮司犯下的那些计算机类的罪行很顺手,外加上严密的布局和复杂的作案心情,真的是推理佳作。

小说的局很妙,通篇都没有正面描述亮和雪穗的接触,最多也是借图书管理员之口说,可能是照片上这个男孩(亮)和雪穗一起在图书馆看书,男孩还剪纸给她,剩下的都是两人分工行动,屡屡犯罪,只为了生存下去的共同利益。亮从事着各种黑色交易,基本没有失手过;而雪穗则从大家闺秀变成少妇、老板、贵妇,合情合理;只是在此期间,7个直接或间接与他们有关系的人消失了,外加源头1973年桐原洋介之死,结局桐原亮司之死,总共9条人命外加4个被夺去灵魂的女孩(雪穗、江利子、藤村都子、筱冢美佳)让亮和雪穗永远只能在白夜中行走。推理小说之妙在于,这个9个人之死都可以变成独立的短篇小说,不管是亮还是雪穗其实都用了不少心机,不过作者很懂得取舍,有些地方则揭开了犯罪手法(和友彦有染的华冈夕子之死以及侦探今枝之死),很有逻辑性;有的地方(松浦之死和雪穗母亲之死)只是一笔带过,让读者自己推理,不寒而栗。更妙的是,在追踪这一个个独立的案件的过程中,箭头都指向当年在大阪的那幢破楼里发生的那件命案,于是故事就游走在现实和过去之间,亮和雪穗两人的生活中,不断有人遇害,通过相关证人的回忆,当年案件的真相越来越清晰, 罪恶之源若隐若现。

至于亮和雪穗之间的情感,通篇都没有描写到两人之间的情愫,但是我的正面解读为他们为了希望而不断犯罪所以格外可悲。

亮司和唯一的朋友园村友彦在告别的时候,曾经说过,“我的人生就像在白夜里走路”(pp240)。我在ptt日剧版看到过一篇评论说亮对雪穗的感情和《嫌疑人X的献身》里石神对邻居的感情有点相似,都是牺牲自我,我很同意。亮一开始轼父的动机很复杂,也许他也早已发觉了父亲的也许只是一时怒火,但是他后来的所有一切都是想让雪穗过的好一点,一半愧疚一半爱慕,他都用情很深。

至于雪穗,在大阪店最终开幕的时候,也曾对店员说,“我的天空里没有太阳,总是黑夜,但并不暗,因为有东西代替了太阳........凭借着这份光,我偏能把黑夜当成白天...” (pp452),不过她也对筱冢一成说过,我不懂得怎么爱男人,不知道她是真的爱亮司还是利用他,她对筱冢也抱着复杂的感情。

最后附一笔,故事里也提到了第一代宅男(otaku)不良代表宫崎勤的案件,除了布局精妙,感情复杂,这部小说也充满了时代性和社会性,故事选择雪穗这样经历的女孩,也算是对这类弱势群体的一种关注。